The comparison between Mr. Wen Zhao and Mr. Wang Zhi'an is the same as Taiwan's public opinion field today

 The comparison between Mr. Wen Zhao and Mr. Wang Zhi'an is the same as Taiwan's public opinion field today

It has been three or four years since I chased Mr. Wenzhao's YouTube program, and it has been nearly a year since I chased Mr. Wang Zhi'an's YouTube program. Before the official comparison, there is another point to add, my opinion of the two of them is completely obtained by watching their YouTube programs, before watching their programs, I have not heard of their names, so there is no inherent impression, of course, this will definitely be a little biased, apologize again: "Wang Bureau" is sorry, there is really no malicious intent, please forgive me!

Before I make a formal comparison, I would like to express my overall opinion of the two teachers.

Teacher Wen Zhao: Knowledgeable and knowledgeable, knowing the past and the present, distinguishing right from wrong without being restricted, knowing the world and not being arrogant, in ancient times it should be the material to enter the cabinet, and now you can only enter the hometown to speak quickly. Teacher Wen Zhao, you have been wronged.

Teacher Wang Zhi'an: Experienced, knowledgeable and eloquent, you can see the big festival from a small place, you can be reasonable, you can sit in the well and watch the sky, and you can talk about the scriptures after going out of the pit. Teacher Wang Zhi'an is difficult for you.

The previous few sentences were a little too much as the overall evaluation of Mr. Wen Zhao, and it made me seem a little "little pink" brain-dead, and I was a little reluctant to change it from the smoothness of the text, forget it, the flesh is numb, the brain is brain-dead, let him go.

The next few sentences are also a bit excessive and a little extreme as an overall evaluation of Mr. Wang Zhi'an, which makes him seem a little "Red Guard" rampant. But I don't want to change it, it's true that because of my love for Mr. Wang Zhi'an's program, I don't vomit and feel unhappy, extreme is extreme, rampant is rampant, and I have already said humble.

I like to chase Mr. Wang Zhi'an's "Wang Ju Shooting" program very much, especially at the beginning, of course I still like it very much after watching more, otherwise I wouldn't have chased it down, but I have watched it too much, and I always feel that Mr. Wang Zhian's program and Mr. Wen Zhao's program always have an indescribable "strange smell" compared with Mr. Wen Zhao's program, and the more directly involved in the Communist Party, the stronger the "strange smell".

Before talking about this weird taste, let's talk about the advantages of Mr. Wang Zhi'an's program compared with Mr. Wen Zhao's program, I think it can be summarized as the following points, first, compared with Mr. Wen Zhao's program, Mr. Wang Zhian's program pays more attention to details, pays more attention to logic, and even says that it is more logically self-consistent, after all, Mr. Wang Zhi'an was born as a reporter, and the reporter of the Communist Party is also a reporter. Second, compared with Mr. Wen Zhao's program, Mr. Wang Zhian's program has more humanistic care, or more humane, he criticizes those who do evil, he sympathizes with the victims, and sometimes even puts forward a lot of very realistic relief opinions, in this era, how precious this is. Although the third point is not very important, it still has to be said that compared with Mr. Wen Zhao's program, Mr. Wang Zhian's program has a wider range of topics and richer content, from political news events, to public news events, and interviews, which are really very rich.

Originally, Mr. Wang Zhi'an's program can point out the above very obvious advantages compared with Mr. Wen Zhao's program, I should prefer Mr. Wang Zhi'an's program, in fact, no, if I think about it carefully, it still has to be attributed to the kind of "weird taste" I felt from Mr. Wang Zhi'an's program, once again, the "weird taste" I want to say is not to doubt the quality of Mr. Wang Zhian's program, let alone to doubt Mr. Wang Zhian's motives and personality, It's just that I have a few very obvious doubts about the views expressed by Mr. Wang Zhi'an in the program, and I think the doubts can be roughly distilled into the following three points.

My first doubt is that Mr. Wang Zhi'an has expressed it more clearly, or he has inadvertently shown that "he is not against the Communist Party, but he has a lot of criticism and opinions about the Communist Party." Or what he means can be that "he has a lot of criticism and opinions about the Communist Party, but he does not oppose the Communist Party." I couldn't help but ask, "Mr. Wang, what are you doing?" "You don't have the illusion of Communist reform all the time.

Of course, Mr. Wang Zhi'an has also directly or indirectly expressed that there is no point in being anti-communist, and it is even more meaningless to shout anti-communist slogans, and I think my answer is that absolute meaning does not exist. Then start from the general end and oppose the Communist Party, the Communist Party will not die out soon, if you criticize the Communist Party, will the Communist Party be able to correct it, just kidding. From the point of view of the end of the branch, for example, a very vicious tragic event occurred due to the bad government of the Communist Party, Mr. Wang Zhian, you made a related comment program, in the program you expressed sympathy for the victims, and you criticized the bad government of the Communist Party, from the practical significance, your program for the future society, can prevent similar things from happening, absolutely impossible, can you reduce the occurrence of similar things, it is possible but the probability is very small, It stands to reason that it is possible to reduce even the probability of a very small decrease, but the fact is that there is another possibility, and it is precisely because of your propaganda that the social effect of this incident will be greatened, and the Communist Party will further increase its efforts to cover up similar incidents in the future, which will increase the severity of similar incidents in the future. If it is the latter possibility, although you have expanded its influence in this matter, due to the overall decrease in the number of similar incidents, your criticism is not improving, but rather reducing the efficiency of the society's enlightenment, and even to the extreme of saying that you are looking for a system bug for the Communist Party, I think this is absolutely the opposite of your original intention, so if it is meaningless to oppose the Communist Party, who can guarantee that your criticism and opinions on the Communist Party must be of good significance?

My second doubt is that Mr. Wang Zhi'an mentioned in the program that he hopes to arouse the awakening of the public through his program, I don't doubt Mr. Wang Zhi'an's original intention and motives, and I don't doubt Mr. Wang Zhi'an's courage and efforts, I just doubt Mr. Wang Zhi'an's own awakening from the root, or always feel that Mr. Wang Zhi'an himself is a little half-asleep consciously or unconscious.

For the past of the Communist Party, Mr. Wang Zhi'an mentioned in the program the criticism and hatred of Mao Zedong, mentioned the affirmation and praise of Deng Xiaoping, and mentioned the tolerance and understanding of Jiang Zemin. I won't mention the innocents killed in vain in order to gain power, but how to count the at least tens of millions of lives that were directly killed after taking power, and who are the accounts of tens of millions of unjust souls, from a historical point of view, they died like garbage, meaningless, and their deaths were even worse than Zhang Xianzhong's rations. I think from some point of view, at least the tens of millions of people who were directly killed died for the surviving innocents, so the surviving innocents and their descendants must find an explanation. Even tens of millions of lives can be sighed, and there is no need to talk about awakening.

Regarding the current situation of the Communist Party, Mr. Wang Zhian has criticized the Central Propaganda Department, the judicial system, the police system, the status quo of medical education, and of course, the "one respect" system, but where is the root of the problem, Mr. Wang Zhian has mentioned it less, at least it is not direct enough, and it is not profound enough. In my understanding, under the consistent system of backwardness, superstition, decay and festering reality in which the party is the government, the government is the state, the country is the people, and the people are the party's private property, it is a sin to hope that the Communist Party will be reformed and to rebel, because they all want its life in fact. As for which one has the higher probability of success, only God knows.

For the future, I think Mr. Wang Zhian should not have imagined China without the Communist Party, thinking that those dreams are unrealistic, and even raised the question of whether China would be fine without the Communist Party? My answer to this is, I don't know if China would be good or bad without the Communist Party? All I know is that it was and is now, because of it, it's really bad, it's bad, and it's going to continue to be bad in the foreseeable future, because of its existence. Heaven and earth are unkind, and all things are used as dogs. If the Qing Dynasty is dead, will the Republic of China be fine? Without Saddam, would Iraq be fine? This kind of question, raised after the demise of the Qing Dynasty and after the death of Saddam, may be regarded as a humane question, if a similar question is raised before the incident happens, and refuted it, I think it should contain more sophistry, like almost all propaganda of the Communist Party, its flavor is strange.

My third question comes from a quote from Mr. Wang Zhi'an, or a few words similar to this sentence, which is probably "There are many talented and capable people in the Communist Party, and the work they do is only to support their families." "First of all, my superficial understanding of this sentence, on the whole, this sentence is true, very true, but I think this sentence also applies to all people involved in Hitler's Nazi fascist cause, including Hitler himself, the biggest difference may only be the degree of application, as for Pol Pot and his followers, it is more suitable or completely applicable to this sentence, after all, the latter is a comrade in the same system as the Communist Party.

Speaking of what I want to deduce, I would like to ask Mr. Wang Zhi'an, you said this, and there are a few words with similar meanings, you mainly want to say that those capable and talented good people are wronged in the Communist Party, or do you want to say that because there are many talented and capable good people in the Communist Party, the Communist Party also has its respectability. If it is the former meaning, I would like to say that countless people now want to suffer such grievances, which can prove that no matter how talented, capable, or good a person is, if he or she is placed outside the Communist Party, he or she will probably suffer more grievances. If it is the second meaning, you can directly talk about the respectability of the Communist Party, and it will be over, there is no need to make such a big detour, and I have to imagine it here.

After talking about the conjecture, I would like to add a meaning, or add an example, the current diplomatic system of the Communist Party is full of miasma, and its propaganda system is even more like eating people and not, and now the people are not living well, and suicide is rampant, the guilt of these two systems can be said to be equal, and they are all indispensable, as a self-conscious bystander, when I condemn these two systems, let alone any capable, talented and good people in them, even the uncles and aunts who clean in these two major systems, I will not let go. Of course, I also have other additions to my condemnation, uncles and aunts who clean up, I'm sorry, you eat this salary, and you are not innocent of my grievances, and of course my grievances against you are completely negligible compared to my hatred for Wang Yi, Zhao Lijian, Hu Xijin, Wu Jing and other real national thieves, my grievances against you are so small that they are not worth a bad word, but I still firmly believe that you are not innocent. What's more, in these two systems, other high-ranking people who are capable, talented, and still good people, think about those low-level people who are suffering and those who commit suicide, which high-ranking person is not an executioner, compared with indirect murder and direct murder, of course, when proving, it takes one more turn or even a few more turns, as for their crimes, do you still need to divide dark and light gray?

Looking back a few times, I feel that the bigger problem is not trivial, but the comparison is too shallow, and the criticism of Mr. Wang Zhi'an himself and Mr. Wang Zhi'an's program is too strong. I'm deeply ashamed of the overly thick question, I'm sorry, there is no malice. I would like to add that Mr. Wen Zhao is more correct than Mr. Wang Zhi'an, and Mr. Wen Zhao's program is more reasonable than Mr. Wang Zhi'an's program.

Those who want to talk about their things should first correct their hearts, then establish their intentions, and then explain their reasoning.

After talking about the comparison between Mr. Wen Zhao and Mr. Wang Zhi'an, it is time to talk about today's public opinion field in Taiwan. I want to briefly discuss today's public opinion field in Taiwan is what I really want to express in this little article, as for the comparison between Mr. Wen Zhao and Mr. Wang Zhi'an, it is more like a pre-dinner snack at most, and even those are all nonsense, I can accept it myself, and a little praise for Mr. Wen Zhao will not affect my disagreement with some of his views, and the excessive criticism of Mr. Wang Zhi'an will not affect my liking of his program.

Today, the situation in the Taiwan Strait is becoming increasingly tense, and the clarion call for war has been rumored and deafening. War is to the death. If you want Taiwan to have as few dead people as possible, it is better not to die people, are you ready for Taiwan? Is Taiwan's public opinion field ready?

Public opinion is a magical thing, so magical that it seems to be a little inappropriate to refer to it with the universal word "thing", invisible, intangible, and even in any language to describe it, the language used will become a little narrow, but it is undeniable that this invisible and intangible thing contains boundless power, sometimes its boundless power can benefit the common people, and sometimes its boundless power can make living beings miserable. Therefore, bring public opinion into Lao Tzu's "Tao Te Ching" in a sentence "Xuan Zhi Xuan Xuan, the door of all wonders." "To understand, I don't think it's an exaggeration.

In fact, I usually pay very little attention to today's public opinion field in Taiwan, and I have watched the "Critical Moment" program on YouTube intermittently, and I have only seen a handful of articles, so I am ashamed to comment on today's public opinion field in Taiwan more shamelessly than to shamelessly criticize Mr. Wang Zhi'an, but I don't think I can be regarded as completely untargeted, after all, I have really followed international news for many years, and because I really like freedom, democracy and openness very much, If I had a soul, I think my liking for freedom, democracy, and openness had penetrated the depths of my soul.

In my humble opinion, democracy, freedom and openness are the cornerstones of almost all the successes of today's Taiwan, and the most dazzling light exuded by today's Taiwan is also democracy, freedom and openness.

Returning to the theme, what I have seen, I think, I think that the biggest feature of today's Taiwan public opinion field is also democracy, freedom and openness, so is the democratic, free and open public opinion field necessarily a good thing for today's Taiwan? I think if you want to answer in 100% certainty, you have to meet two virtual preconditions, or either of these two conditions can be satisfied, the first virtual condition is that today's Taiwan Strait crisis does not exist, and the second virtual condition is that Taiwan is larger, large enough to compete with her enemies.

In my fantasy world, I hope that the two conditions mentioned can be met, but unfortunately the sky does not follow people's wishes, fantasy is fantasy after all, and the conditions that come out of the virtual can only be virtual. Therefore, Taiwan's democratic, free and open public opinion field today is not necessarily a good thing for today's Taiwan, and at least it cannot be 100 percent certain. Of course, I will also briefly analyze this point of view from three aspects.

The first point is that democracy must be spineless, it is absolutely, otherwise the United States would never have defeated fascism in World War II in history. However, if the democratic public opinion field is spineless, I think there should be some truth, especially when the external pressure is strong enough. You think, democracy is coming, there must be discussion, discussion must be compromised, and what backbone is there to talk about after compromise.

Second, the free field of public opinion must be overgrown with weeds, prejudice and sophistry. What do you think, what is the essence of the free opinion field, the essence of the free public opinion field is to not block all kinds of voices as much as possible, there are many voices, if you want to come out, you can only see whose voice is louder, and it is precisely prejudice and sophistry that have the essential attribute of having a loud voice, so it is not logical if prejudice and sophistry are not full of them.

Third, an open field of public opinion will make many sober people shut up because they cherish their feathers. You think, in the open field of public opinion, even if the word of God enters the field, it will become a target, and if it becomes a target, it will be attacked, and if it is attacked, it will fall into right and wrong, and who will not care about this if it is really sober.

The above is basically the basic view of Taiwan's public opinion field today, and we ask for your understanding if there is anything wrong, and it is indeed not fully prepared. Of course, I seem to have only raised questions about Taiwan's public opinion today, but did not give answers, not because I don't want to, but because I am indeed limited by my intellect and beyond my ability. However, given my limited level of intelligence, I would like to repeat the sentence mentioned above: "Those who want to say things should first correct their hearts, then establish their intentions, and then explain their reasoning." ”。

At the end of this article, I would like to conclude with a little anecdote that many people may have heard of. In a public interview, Mr. Ni Kuang said that he was really wronged by the rumors that he said that "prostitutes are more credible than the Communist Party", he said that he did not say it, and he did not know who said it, and he explained why he did not say it, because people who knew him well knew that he respected prostitutes very much, and "prostitutes are more credible than the Communist Party" was very insulting to prostitutes, and he would not say this.

Sometimes I think that if there were more or enough people in Hong Kong back then who could not cherish their feathers like Mr. Ni Kuang, Hong Kong today may not be what it is today. Although it can only be possible, if you think about the situation of Hong Kong today, even if it is only possible, how precious it is!

Today's Taiwan, is Taiwan's public opinion field ready today?

April 15, 2023